How to Fix Soft 404 Errors

Time to read
0 minutes


Understanding Soft 404 Errors

Soft 404 errors can be perplexing to webmasters, as they affect a site’s SEO and visibility in search engine results. Properly identifying and addressing soft 404 issues is crucial for maintaining search performance.

What Is a Soft 404 Error?

A soft 404 error occurs when a non-existent page (a page that should return a ‘404 not found’ status) displays a ‘200 OK’ status instead, misleading both users and search engines. Unlike a traditional 404 error, where a page clearly does not exist, a soft 404 error miscommunicates that a page is present when it is not, resulting in a poor user experience.

The Impact of Soft 404s on SEO

The presence of soft 404 errors can significantly hinder a website’s SEO efforts. These errors consume crawl budget and can lead to a decrease in ranking and visibility. Search engines prefer to index content that provides value to users, and pages with soft 404 errors can be viewed as inaccurate or low-quality content, thereby affecting the website’s overall search performance.

How Search Engines Interpret Soft 404s

Search engines like Google use tools such as Google Search Console to identify soft 404s. They interpret these errors as a sign of poor website maintenance, which can negatively affect the indexing of legitimate content. A soft 404 page that remains listed can confuse search engine algorithms, leading to potential issues with content ranking and visibility in search results. It’s essential for webmasters to use provided tools to detect and rectify soft 404 errors to preserve the integrity of their site in the eyes of search engines.

Diagnosing and Identifying Soft 404 Issues

In addressing soft 404 errors, webmasters must first diagnose and accurately identify instances of such issues on their websites. This process is vital to ensure that the legitimate pages are not mistaken for soft 404s, and that search engines correctly index the site’s content.

Using Google Search Console

Google Search Console is a pivotal tool for webmasters to identify soft 404 errors. They can navigate to the Coverage report to locate URLs labeled as soft 404s. This report details the pages that Googlebot attempted to crawl but deemed to have an issue. Webmasters should use the URL Inspection Tool within the console for a closer examination of the flagged URLs to confirm if they are false alarms or genuine soft 404 errors.

Analyzing with SEO Tools

SEO tools like Screaming Frog and DeepCrawl offer in-depth site audits, scrutinizing a website’s HTTP response codes. This analysis allows for the identification of URLs returning ambiguous or incorrect response codes that may signal a soft 404 error. Comprehensive crawling tools aid in evaluating a site’s technical SEO aspects, economizing the crawl budget by flagging pages that need attention.

Manual Checks and Common Causes

Manual checks are essential for webmasters to understand the underlying causes of soft 404 errors. These may include thin content, broken links, duplicate content, or mismatches between the content and the HTTP response code. Regularly reviewing content management systems (CMS) for updates or errors can also reduce the incidence of soft 404s. The specific signs they should look for are pages that exist but do not actually provide content and pages that should display a proper 404 error but don’t.

Resolving Soft 404 Errors

Soft 404 errors can confuse search engines and create a negative user experience, as they provide an HTTP response code indicating a page is OK when in fact it’s not properly available. Addressing these errors can improve your site’s SEO and user experience.

Identifying Soft 404s:
First, use tools like Google Search Console to detect soft 404s. They highlight these errors in the coverage section, where you can troubleshoot with the Validate Fix button after making corrections.

Debugging Content Issues:
Examine each page reported as a soft 404. Check for misplaced JavaScript handling or CMS content rendering issues, ensuring the page loads intended content correctly. If content should indeed be removed, apply a 404 or 410 status code.

Appropriate Use of Redirects:
When a page has been moved or no longer offers value, use a 301 redirect to send users and web crawlers to a relevant active page. This server configuration helps in maintaining link equity and ranking positions while improving site navigation.

Optimizing Indexing:

  • Remove soft 404 pages from sitemaps to prevent search engine confusion.
  • For ecommerce websites or during a website migration, ensure category and product pages are active or properly redirected.
  • After making changes, request indexing through search engine tools to update their records.

Enhancing User Experience:
Consider creating a custom 404 page that provides helpful navigation options, reducing negative user experience and keeping visitors engaged even when a page is not found.

Eliminating Redundancies:
If multiple soft 404 pages exist without unique content, consolidate pages or deindex them to focus on stronger, value-adding pages within the search engine index.

Server and Hosting Adjustments:
Be sure that your hosting setup and server configuration are not contributing to soft 404 errors due to incorrect handling of missing pages.

Taking these steps should alleviate issues regarding soft 404s, keeping both users and search engines content with the quality of your website.

Frequently Asked Questions

In this section, readers will find answers to common queries about resolving soft 404 errors, identifying the differences from hard 404s, and understanding their impact on SEO and user experience.

What are the steps to correct soft 404 errors in WordPress sites?

WordPress users can address soft 404 errors by ensuring their pages return the correct HTTP status code and updating or redirecting content as necessary. Plugins or manually checking redirect rules can assist in correcting these errors.

How can one identify and resolve soft 404 errors through Google Search Console?

Users can identify soft 404 errors in Google Search Console by checking the Coverage report. They should look for any URLs labeled ‘Soft 404’ and assess the reported pages, then make the appropriate changes to the content or HTTP response.

What distinguishes a soft 404 from a hard 404, and how does it affect website functionality?

A soft 404 is a page that exists but suggests non-existence to users, often returning a ‘page not found’ message without the appropriate HTTP 404 status code. A hard 404, on the other hand, correctly returns a 404 status code, indicating a non-existent page. Soft 404s can waste crawl budget and confuse search engines.

In what ways can Screaming Frog be utilized to detect and fix soft 404 errors?

Screaming Frog can detect soft 404 errors by crawling a website and identifying which pages provide content that appear to be errors but do not return the HTTP 404 status code. Users can then analyze and update these pages to either add relevant content or issue the correct response code.

What strategies can be implemented to address 404 errors effectively in SEO?

Effective strategies include updating or redirecting nonexistent pages, providing a custom 404 page with links to relevant content, and frequently monitoring for 404 errors using tools like Google Search Console to avoid negative SEO impact.

How does a soft 404 error impact a website’s search engine ranking and user experience?

Soft 404 errors can negatively impact a website’s search engine ranking as they consume crawl budget and can be interpreted as thin content by search engines. They also impair user experience by leading users to non-useful pages without proper direction.

Is this you?

💸 You have been spending thousands of dollars on buying backlinks in the last months. Your rankings are only growing slowly.

❌You have been writing more and more blog posts, but traffic is not really growing.

😱You are stuck. Something is wrong with your website, but you don`t know what.

Let the SEO Copilot give you the clicks you deserve.